8 Best Restaurants in Blue Hill Peninsula, Maine

44 North Coffee

$ Fodor's choice

This place offers amazing (and equitably sourced) coffee and invites you to take a minute to have a conversation while you wait for your slow-pour brew to flow through a colorful, custom-built wooden drip bar. Grab a pastry supplied by a variety of local bakers---if there are any left when you arrive. 

7 Main St., Deer Isle, Maine, 04627, USA
207-348--5208
Known For
  • great coffee
  • pastries from Brooksville's Tinder Hearth Bakery
  • no Wi-Fi
Restaurants Details
Rate Includes: Closed Sun.

Bagaduce Lunch

$ Fodor's choice

This tidy little joint next to the reversing falls on the Bagaduce River is the perfect place for a lunch of clam, shrimp, haddock, or scallop baskets that come with onion rings or chips; there are also hot dogs, burgers, and chicken fingers. Picnic tables dot this nub of land surrounded on three sides by water, and you can walk onto the pier (or moor your kayak or boat there) for tidal estuary views and glimpses of seals, bald eagles, and ospreys. At low tide kids can explore the shore.

145 Franks Flat Rd., Penobscot, Maine, 04617, USA
207-326–4197
Known For
  • outdoor dining only
  • the views
  • fresh seafood
Restaurants Details
Rate Includes: Closed mid-Sept.–late Apr. and Wed. in summer

Bucklyn Coffee

$ Fodor's choice

This tiny, friendly shop serves big, flavorful coffee and interesting sweet and savory pastries.

103 Main St., Blue Hill, Maine, USA
917-971–3246
Known For
  • Maine-roasted beans
  • coffee served anyway you like it
  • great place for a morning or early afternoon pick-me-up
Restaurants Details
Rate Includes: Closed Sun.

Recommended Fodor's Video

Barncastle Restaurant

$

Enjoy this inn restaurant's small-plate dishes, local beers, and craft cocktails in the quiet dining room or the rustic pub.

125 South St., Blue Hill, Maine, USA
207-374–2300
Known For
  • contemporary twists on comfort food classics
  • deck seating in nice weather
  • live music on weekends
Restaurants Details
Rate Includes: No lunch

El El Frijoles

$

Burritos, bowls, nachos, empanadas, and tacos filled with crab, fish, lobster, or meat and served with a full range of fiery accoutrement are made fresh daily at this taqueria, whose name is a play on L.L. Bean!

41 Caterpillar Rd., Maine, 04673, USA
207-359–2486
Known For
  • local favorite
  • made-from-scratch Mexican classics
  • festive, family-oriented atmosphere
Restaurants Details
Rate Includes: Closed Sat.–Tues.

Sandy’s Blue Hill Café

$

Open for breakfast, lunch, and weekend brunch, this place has a mix of standard and surprising offerings, including a great falafel platter. If you want dinner, you can select from such house-made frozen dishes as beef stew, vegetable and cheese enchiladas, or Georgia onion pie. In summer, the café occasionally hosts special concert lunches and dinners (reservations required).

Strong Brewing & Kitchen

$

Good beer, pizza, and, occasionally, live music—it's a combination the fits perfectly into a lazy day of lazily exploring the Blue Hill Peninsula.

7 Rope Ferry Rd., Maine, 04676, USA
207-359–2687
Known For
  • outdoor dining
  • house-brewed porters, ales, and lagers
  • wood-fired oven
Restaurants Details
Rate Includes: Closed Tues.–Thurs.