Fodor's Expert Review Station
Editor's Note: This location is no longer in operation.
Entering the property is like walking into a secret garden, pretty but overgrown, and it's easy to miss their quirky red-and-blue rooster sign, but the smell of smoky goodness in the air will signal that you've arrived. In a chic yet unpretentious farmhouse some incredible food awaits. Grilled octopus with orange and arugula is bright and fresh, grilled polenta and Brie has a nice crust and hint of smoke, and the unassuming little beef empanada explodes with flavor—and that's just the small plates. Entrees include lamb chops with salsa verde; braised chicken with egg mole, kale, and dijon; and house-made tagliatelle with lobser. Try one of their unique cocktails: the Thirsty Rooster has kick, and The Grand Poo Bah is smoky and sweet.
Quick Facts
412 Montauk Hwy. and Old Country Rd.
East Quogue,
New York
11942,
USA
631-996-4050